Protest 12 CHN55005 (Beneteau 40.7) CHN55026 (Beneteau 40.7)

Date 01 Nov 2015
Class Beneteau 40.7
Race 5
Hearing 00:00
Abstract

An incident which occurred approaching the leeward mark in Race 5

Facts Found
  1. 005 and 026 were approaching the second leeward mark in race 5
  2. At the zone 026 was overlapped and outside of 00
  3. 5A collision occurred between 005 and 026 causing damage
  4. The damage was mino
  5. r005 hailed protest and displayed a flag
  6. The umpire signalled that 026 had broken a rule
  7. 026 carried out a penalty turn
Conclusion

026 failed to give 005 mark room as required by r18.2

Rules Applicable

Rules 18.2, N1.4(a)

Decision

026 breached rule 18.2 but as she carried out a penalty turn no further penalty applies

Protest Committee

John Doerr (IJ GBR)
Oleg Ilyin (IJ RUS)
Howard Elliott (IJ AUS)